Lyrics:

“Our Sick Story (Thus Far)” appears on the band’s Best of Atreyu compilation album.
When we danced
So pristine and
Knee deep in sin, balls deep in hate
I see your face
I see your face and it tears me
Tears me up
My mouth is full of love
My head is held in shame

When you kiss me
Do you still taste her?
Are you thinking of
Are you thinking of me?
With your lips pressed tightly up against his skin
Does your body still scream my name?
Does your body still scream my name?

Hold your breath and keep it
Trapped with secrets
'Til you're turning cold blue with guilt
Still no blood is spilt
Had I seen the plot twists coming
Would I have checked out the book?
And even if I was dead
You would never be off the fucking hook

When you kiss me
Do you still taste her?
Are you thinking of
Are you thinking of me?
With your lips pressed tightly up against his skin
Does your body still scream my name?
Does your body still scream my...

Can you take it while I fake it?
Can you take it while I fake it?


Cross your heart, false your heart
Cross your heart, false your heart

When you kiss me
Do you still taste her?
Are you thinking of
Are you thinking of me?
With your lips pressed tightly up against his skin
Does your body still scream my name?
Does your body still scream my name?

Cross your heart, false your heart
Cross your heart, false your heart