Lyrics:

Blaine:
Once in your life you find her
Someone that turns your heart around
And next thing you know you're closing down the town

Artie:
Wake up and it's still with you
Even though you left her way across town
Wondering to yourself 'Hey, what've I found?'

Roderick (with Alumni and New Directions Boys):
(When you get caught between the Moon and New York City)
I know it's crazy but it's true
(If you get caught between the Moon and New York City)
The best that you can do
The best that you can do is fall in love

Mason:
Arthur, he does as he pleases
All of his life, he's mastered choice
And, deep in his heart, he's just, he's just a boy

Spencer:
Living his life one day at a time
He's showing himself a really good time
He's laughing about the way they want him to be

Blaine (with Alumni and New Directions Boys):
(When you get caught between the Moon and New York City)
I know it's crazy but it's true
(If you get caught between the Moon and New York City)
The best that you can do (Spencer with Alumni and New Directions Boys: The best that you can do)
The best that you can do is fall in love

Artie with Alumni and New Directions Boys:
When you get caught between the Moon and New York City

Spencer:
I know it's crazy but it's true

Artie with Alumni and New Directions Boys:
If you get caught between the Moon and New York City

Artie (with Alumni and New Directions Boys):
The best that you can do (Blaine: The best that you can do)
(The best that you can do)

Blaine with Artie:
Is fall in love

Roderick with Alumni and New Directions Boys (Artie):
When you get caught between the Moon and New York City
(Oh, I know it's crazy but it's true)
If you get caught between the Moon and New York City

Artie:
The best that you can do (Spencer: The best that you can do)

Blaine:
The best that you can do

Artie with Blaine:
Is fall in love