Lyrics:

Rachel was a year older
When I was in the second grade
I thought she might know everything
I took her word like a golden ring
I asked her how to win my man
And she said, 'I know just the thing'
Gave me lipgloss and a hair toss
And, after school, a lesson in kissing
She called me by the name of her crush
I couldn't decide if she was Cole or Justin
I think I called her baby or darling
Most the time
We'd take turns being seduced
Imagining the day it would come into use
Imagining the day we'd start breaking hearts
And taking names
She wanted a three story house
I wanted to live by a body of water
With my children and their father
Children and their father
Three sons and a beautiful daughter
Oh

Rachel's family moved out of town
I don't remember when we stopped hanging out
But I still wear a letter R charm on my bracelet
And wonder if she thinks of me as her first kiss