Lyrics:

Yeah, I found you there on my front steps
Mascara eyes and a threadbare dress
Said, 'Is it okay if I stay for awhile?'

You were talking fast and feeling down
So you spent the week, he was out of town
Woke up alone, I should have known you'd be gone

I'm tired of being your other guy
I wanna be more than your good time

But your love is breaking my heart
Come on little pretty, let me out of your dark
Oh, isn't it a pity?

In a Cadillac with the backseat torn out
Looking back I should have turned it around
Love is breaking my heart, so let me go little pretty

Oh, tell me baby, what's your plan?
'Cause I don't really understand
There's got to be a way for me to get to you

Yeah, I got you in when you lost your key
And scored some pills so you could sleep
I went home, woke up alone thinking about you

I'm tired of being your other guy
I wanna be more than your good time

Because your love is breaking my heart
Come on little pretty, let me out of your dark
Oh, isn't it a pity?

In a Cadillac with the backseat torn out
Looking back I should have turned it around
Love is breaking my heart, so let me go little pretty

And don't you call me up when you're in need
And don't you baby 'cause I'm in too deep
I can barely breathe

And I'm tired of trying to tell you
That your love is breaking my heart

Come on little pretty
Let me out of your dark
Oh, isn't it a pity?

In a Cadillac with the backseat torn out
Looking back I should have turned it around
Now love is breaking my heart

Come on little pretty
Let me out of your dark
Oh, isn't it a pity?

In a Cadillac with the backseat torn out
Looking back I should have turned it around
Love is breaking my heart, so let me go little pretty, yeah

So let me go little pretty, yeah, yeah
So let me go little pretty, yeah
So let me go little pretty, yeah, yeah
So let me go little pretty
Breaking my heart, baby won't you go to sleep?