Lyrics:

When Jamie died
I didn't understand
The eternity of my sadness
I wish I could have prevented it
Mmm-hmm
When I rest in bed
Dream about how I could have
Lived and played with my brother
How I wish that I could have saved him

And if wishing could bring him back
He'd be here with me today
But then I remember...
It happened anyway

When I look at pictures
And imagine what he would be like
Now a dozen years old
I wish I could have saved him from agelessness

And if crying could bring him back
He'd be here with me today
But then I remember...
It happened anyway

When I think of why and how
He was with us and he left us
I wish I could have prevented it
And stopped his death, and saved him from
Never needing breath for birthday candles...
For Birthday candles

And if wishing could bring him back
He'd be here with me today
But then I remember...

When Jamie died we didn't understand
Oh, but then I remember
It happened anyway
It happened anyway

It happened anyway
It happened anyway