Lyrics:

She made him mix tapes
He made her laugh
Innocence was easy
When that's all you have
The Sundays spent in bed
Hearing words our bodies said
We should have let it end
Right there and then
Take a good look
Take it all in
'Cause we're nothing like her or
Like him anymore
Time's like rain
And even love can rust
Something's changed
I think it's us

He held her secrets
Like they were glass
She thought he had the answers
The ones that nobody has

Take a good look
Take it all in
'Cause we're nothing like her or him
Anymore
Time's like rain
And even love can rust
Something's changes
C'mon you know it's us

Was the truth ever spoken?
Where there promises broken
Or did I just open
My eyes?
Someday we just might meet
On a New York City street
And we'll see ourselves come back
Like a snapshot grey and black

Take a good look
Take it all in
'Cause we're nothing like her or like him
Anymore
Time's like rain
And even love can rust
Something's changed

I wish it wasn't us
I wish it wasn't us