Lyrics:

The first time you took my heart
Was the first time I walked through the dark
The first time my heart almost died
The first time I survived

Everything here still reminds me of you
The dreams of your touch make it hard to get through
All the words that I said, I said cause I knew
I'd never get over you

Can we ever get it right
Can we stare down another night
We're going round and round
Pain takes another ride
I'm falling down and down
'Cause heaven is hell tonight

It cuts so deep
That I'm damned for living
With blood on my hands
Is there no forgiving
Let's stay together
And swear we'll never
Never give up and break away
We can't make the wrong into the right time
But can we make it feel like the first time

Since you're not here to hold
My heart has turned to stone
No prayer will take me away from the cold
Just you can save my soul

Take it, ooh take it all, like there's nothing there
Break it, break it down like you just don't care
We're standing hand in hand miles away from touch
I need you more and more, I'm holding on for love

It cuts so deep
That I'm damned for living
With blood on my hands
Is there no forgiving
Let's stay together
And swear we'll never
Never give up and break away
We can't make the wrong into the right time
But can we make it feel like the first time
Oh, can we make it real
Can we make it feel like the first time

Let's stay together
And swear we'll never
Never give up and break away
We can't make the wrong into the right time
But can we make it feel like the first time
Can we make it real

It cuts so deep
That I'm damned for living
With blood on my hands
Is there no forgiving
Let's stay together
And swear we'll never
Never give up and break away
We can't make the wrong into the right time
But can we make it feel like the first time
Can we make it feel
Can we make it real
Can we make it feel like the first time
If we make it real
And a heart can always heal
Then I know we can make it feel
Like the first time