Lyrics:

Ey... 'ey... 'ey... 'ey
'Are you goin' to the party on Saturday,' she asked, I said I didn't know
See, ever since I saw you on the back of some guy's bicycle, well, I've been feelin' kinda so-so
So, girl don't act so surprised, got that look in your light-blue eyes, you can stop pretendin'
Yeah, I been watchin' the movie all along, wonderin' if there was gonna be an ending
To the story, to the story, to the story - I guess I'll never know
See, I was runnin' as fast as I could, sayin' the things I thought I should, but it was just a little too slow

Oh, Elizabeth, don't keep me guessin' I opened up the door and saw you undressin'
The words came out, one after another
You shoulda been my high school lover
Oh, you shoulda been my oh-oh-whoa
You shoulda been my oh-oh-oh
You shoulda been my oh-oh-whoa
You shoulda been my oh-oh

'Did you get the letters that I sent last summer', you asked again and again
Well they been pilin' up on the top shelf in my closet - yeah, and I read them every now and then
It's got me feelin' kinda stuck like what the fuck is goin' on - someone tell me what is happening
Yeah, you been actin' like you're too cool for far too long - it's okay it's just kind of embarassin'
See, I been sneakin', I been sneakin', I been sneakin', wonderin' just what I'll see
You turned around and stared, you squinted then you glared and I was leanin' back in the passenger seat

Oh, Elizabeth, don't keep me guessin' I opened up the door and saw you undressin'
The words came out, one after another
You shoulda been my high school lover
Oh, you shoulda been my oh-oh-whoa
You shoulda been my oh-oh-oh
You shoulda been my oh-oh-whoa
You shoulda been my oh-oh
You shoulda been my oh-oh
High school lover
High school lover
High school lover
High school lover
High school lover
High school lover
High school lover
High school lover